The ‘Top Ten’ surnames of Waters Upton

Back in 2023, in connection with the tenth anniversary of the founding of the Society for One-Place Studies, I proposed the blogging prompt Ten (hashtag #OnePlaceStudies10). One of the ideas I put forward for blogging on that theme was ‘the top ten surnames of your OPS’ and, having suggested it, I decided to have a go myself. So began a deep dive into the surnames of Waters Upton’s residents, and in due course a blog post. Originally shared on the Society’s website, I am now adding a longer version of it to the Waters Upton website.

The first question that arose when I embarked on this quest was: “How exactly do I work out what the ‘top ten’ surnames of Waters Upton were?” I decided to use data from the nine censuses from 1841 to 1921 inclusive. Counting variants of any given last name (e.g. Brown and Browne, or Picken and Pickin) as a single family name, I established that 236 different surnames were recorded at Waters Upton on the nine censuses. Of those, 192 occurred less than ten times in total – including 92 which appeared only once.

The number of people enumerated in Waters Upton parish on each census from 1841 to 1921 was, on average, just 201. As a result of this, looking at surnames on any one census, while interesting, did not lead to any meaningful conclusions. In many years a surname could get into the ‘Top Ten’ by virtue of it being borne by just six people!

The method I finally arrived at for calculating the Top Ten Surnames of Waters Upton was based on counting the number of individual surname holders enumerated in the parish across all of the nine census years, counting each individual only once regardless of the number of censuses they appeared in.

So, I would establish the Top Ten surnames of Waters Upton over the period from 1841 to 1921. After a fashion, that is. My chosen method would fail to include any of the people who lived in the parish between censuses. However, given that it would be impossible to identify all of those ‘in-betweeners,’ using the decennial snapshots of the parochial population provided by the censuses was the only way to go.

The Top Ten

An old black and white photo (from a postcard) showing a three-bay, two-storey house with a tiled roof and end stacks, stood at the junction of two roads. Above the house, the names Woolley, Cartwright, Morgan, Evans, Lloyd, Bennett, Davies, Jones, Matthews and Tudor have been added in various font styles and colours.

The results of my calculations (with the number of surname holders in brackets) were as follows:

1.

2.

3.

4 =

6.

7 =

9 =

Wooley (52)

Cartwright (32)

Morgan (31)

Evans and Lloyd (29 each)

Bennett (27)

Davies and Jones (26 each)

Matthews and Tudor (25 each)

Looking at this list, one of the first things that struck me was that six out of the ten surnames – Morgan, Evans, Lloyd, Davies, Jones and Tudor – had Welsh origins. This was no great surprise given that Waters Upton lies in a county on England’s border with Wales. These family names do of course occur at high frequencies elsewhere too. “Commonly occurring surnames dominate Top Ten” would hardly be a shocking finding – but to what extent was that the case?

In checking my data to make sure that I didn’t double-count individuals who were recorded on more than one census, I found many who were enumerated on multiple occasions. The record was held by a William Matthews, enumerated at Waters Upton eight times from 1851 to 1921 inclusive; he appears in the story A fatal tricycle accident at Waters Upton.

It wasn’t just individuals who were ‘long-stayers’ in the parish – there were families which remained in (or returned to) Waters Upton over two or more generations. The long-term presence of such families would certainly have an impact on the Top Ten surnames.

So, high frequency surnames occurring, erm, frequently, and ‘faithful families’ perpetuating their family names – to what extent did each of these two factors influence the final results? In the discussion that follows, the term ‘descendants’ includes women who ‘married in.’

Cartwright and Jones

At one end of the scale there were the Cartwrights and the Joneses. The 26 Joneses were comprised of a family of eight, two families of four, a married couple, a mother and her child, and six other individuals. None of the families were represented by more than two generations (i.e. parents and children). The surname Jones appears to have made it into my Top Ten almost entirely because it was a very high frequency surname.

Photo of part of the war memorial brass inside the church at Waters Upton, showing the name Private J T Cartwright (Cheshire Regiment) followed by the words: Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends.
Private John Thomas Cartwright, whose sacrifice during the First World War is remembered on the war memorial brass inside the church at Waters Upton. Photo by the author.

As for the Cartwrights, Sarah the widow of George Cartwright and her descendants account for 10 of 32 people bearing that surname on census returns; the rest were from four other families. Two of the families had members of three generations enumerated in Waters Upton. I suspect that further research might find that two or more of the apparently separate Cartwright families were in fact related. As things stand however, the surname probably appears in the Top Ten largely – but not entirely – because it was a commonly occurring one.

Morgan, Lloyd and Davies

With around half to two thirds of their numbers represented by members of three to four generations of single families, the surnames Morgan, Lloyd, and Davies claim their places in the Top Ten through a combination of factors. All are fairly high-frequency family names, but their presence in the parish was strengthened by families who were present in the parish for three or four generations.

Photo of a gravestone in waters Upton churchyard, with the names of four members of the Morgan family (John, his widow Emma, and their children William Edward and Mary Ann.

The leading contributor to the Morgans’ success was the family of John Morgan, surgeon and apothecary of Waters Upton, and his wife Emma, née Woodfin. The first appearance by this family on a census at Waters Upton was in 1851. These Morgans were represented in the parish censuses from 1881 by John and Emma’s son Robert Flower Morgan, his wife Eliza (née Blantern) and their descendants. Two sons of Robert and Eliza, John Stanley Morgan and William Edward Morgan, then carried the surname through to the 1921 census (and beyond). The surgeon’s family accounted for 22 of the 31 Morgans recorded on censuses at Waters Upton.

14 of the 29 Lloyds enumerated at Waters Upton were members of a family headed by Wiiliam and his wife Elizabeth, née Wild. This couple and their children first appear in the parish on the 1861 census, with William transitioning from agricultural labourer to small farmer, at The Terrill, by 1871.

The surname Davies was as frequent as Jones across the nine censuses (each being borne by 26 individuals). However exactly half of the Davies representatives (13) were from one family, that of the Rev John Bayley Davies (who features in several blog posts here including In support of the school at Waters Upton) and his wife Susan Anslow, née Juckes.

Evans, Bennett and Tudor

In the case of the Evanses, the Bennetts and the Tudors, over 80% of the holders of each of those surnames were members of single families, each with four to five generations enumerated at Waters Upton across all nine censuses from 1841 to 1921. The progenitors in question were:

  • William Evans, a shoemaker in 1841, and wife Mary, née Higgins; with their descendants they contributed 24 of the 29 Evanses recorded on Waters Upton censuses
  • Charles Bennett, enumerated as a servant in 1841, whose son Thomas, a shoemaker, married Martha Icke and took up residence by 1841 at what would become number 17 Waters Upton; this Bennett family accounts for all but one of the 27 Bennetts enumerated at Waters Upton
  • Samuel Tudor, a bricklayer in 1841, and wife Eleanor, née Humphreys; this couple and their descendants together made up 22 of the 25 Tudors on Waters Upton censuses

Matthews and Woolley, the ‘faithful families’

Finally, two surnames recorded on Waters Upton’s censuses were each borne exclusively by members of a single family, spanning five generations. Down at the bottom of the Top Ten in joint ninth place, everyone with the surname Matthews was descended from William (baptised 1743 at Waters Upton) and Mary (born around 1737).

Photo of part of a brass tablet, a Roll of Honour naming 40 men from Waters Upton parish who served during the First World War, and survived.
Part of the Roll of Honour brass in the porch of Waters Upton St Michael, showing six of the 10 Woolley men named on it (and one of the four Bennetts).

The ultimate example of surname borne by a ‘faithful family’ however was Woolley, the clear leader of the Top Ten chart. All 52 of Waters Upton’s Woolleys enumerated from 1841 to 1921 were descended from, or married to men descended from, William Woolley (baptised in 1759 at High Ercall) and Elizabeth, née Downes (probably the one baptised at Waters Upton in 1760).

In conclusion, although the idea of compiling a ‘Top Ten Surnames of my One-Place Studies’ article seemed like a bit of fun, I found the exercise to be fascinating. It focussed my mind on Waters Upton’s census data and made me analyse it in new ways, generating a number of ideas for further study in the process.

Towards a house history of… Lower House (Part 1)

Lower House, a three storey, red brick farmhouse, stands on the northern edge of Waters Upton village, on the West side of the road leading to Harebutt Bank and beyond. A report ⇗ produced for Telford and Wrekin Council in 2009 described the building as “an important introduction to Waters Upton” to those approaching the village via that road. It has stood there, silently greeting residents and visitors alike, since at least the 1700s – with the possibility that it, or an earlier building with the same name, performed that role even further back in time.

An extract from a large-scale Ordnance Survey map published in 1886 showing part of a village with its buildings, roads, ponds, field boundaries and trees. Lower House is named, and has been coloured red. Other buildings named are a school, and The Hall.
Extract from a 6 inch to the mile scale Ordnance Survey Map (published 1886) showing the North-east end of the village of Waters Upton. Lower House has been coloured red. Map reproduced with the permission of the National Library of Scotland ⇗ under a Creative Commons licence ⇗.

A List entry and a Chancery decree roll…

Because of its special architectural or historic interest, Lower House was listed on 8 Apr 1983. It is categorised as Grade II, with its list entry ⇗ (on the Historic England website) providing basic details of the building, and of the features which make it of special interest.

The List entry suggests that Lower House is an eighteenth century house which was remodelled in the early nineteenth century. I say ‘suggests’ because List entries are not always accurate ⇗ when it comes to the ages of the buildings they describe. And, as I noted above, there might be evidence of the Lower House – or at least a Lower House – existing at Waters Upton in the seventeenth century.

That evidence is in a Chancery decree roll held by The National Archives at Kew. I would have been blissfully unaware of this document, were it not for the Anglo-American Legal Tradition ⇗ website, a treasure trove of photos depicting TNA’s Medieval and Early Modern documents. Abstracts of the contents of many of those photos have also been created, and are searchable – which is how I discovered, via a site search for ‘Waters Upton’, the earliest mention I have found so far of Lower House.

C78 1723 ⇗ is the name of the page containing the aforementioned mention. C78 ⇗ is TNA’s reference for their collection of Chancery decree rolls, and 1723 is the year of the roll in question. An entry on that roll ⇗ dated 4 May in 1723 recorded details of a dispute over property including “all that other Messuage or Tenemt. called the Lower House in Waters Upton”.

The Chancery decree roll contains details of a number of legal documents relating to Lower House, including indentures dated the 25th and 26th June 1697. Those indentures related to “the Lower House or Hughes House“ – the latter name providing a possible clue as to the identity of the original owner of the property.

Was this the same building as the remodelled house of the same name that stands in Waters Upton today? Or was it an earlier abode, on the same spot or even elsewhere in the village, which has not survived? Given the issues with estimated building dates English Heritage listings, I suspect the former.

Brick dentil eaves and voussoired lintels…

A photo a three storey, three bay, red-brick house, seen at an angle so that front of the house faces slightly to our right, and the side wall faces slightly to our left. The photo is annotated to highlight three architectural features: the two end stacks, a gable end, and the three bays.

The List entry’s description of this dwelling’s architectural features is something we can be more certain about. Lower House is a three bay, three storey, red brick structure, with a tiled roof which has gabled ends and brick end stacks. Beneath the eaves of the roof is a brick dentil eaves course, with bricks sticking out in tooth-like fashion. (Hopefully the labelled pictures I have provided will help with interpreting some of these architectural terms; you may also find this glossary ⇗ useful.)

A photo showing part of the roof on a red-brick house. The photo is annotated to highlight the brick dentil eaves course at the top of the wall just below the roof.

The sash windows have glazing bars to create the appearance of multiple panes of glass. Above the windows are voussoired lintels with keyblocks.

A photo showing three windows in the wall of a red-brick house. The frames and the lintels above are painted white. The photo is annotated to highlight the following features: glazing bars on the windows; voussoired lintels above the windows; and keyblocks in the middle of the lintels.

The central front doorcase has a reeded pilaster on either side, topped by an entablature with a panelled frieze. There are also panelled reveals and, above the panelled door, a rectangular fanlight. Apologies for not having a great photo of the door – when photographing the house I had no idea I would one day use the images in the way that I am now doing!

A photo showing the top half of the front door of a red-brick house. The door and frame are painted white. The photo is annotated to highlight the following features: a reeded pilaster; a fanlight; an entablature; and a frieze.

Structural elements of the late nineteenth century front garden are included in the List entry for Lower House. There is a dwarf brick wall with stone coping, and a fence of wrought iron railings with spear heads, at each end of which is a matching gate.

Earth Closet, Coal House, Tool House, Pig Pens…

Lower House as a messuage ⇗ (to use one of the terms used in the 1723 decree roll mentioned above) has always consisted of more than just the house itself. There are also the outbuildings and land that goes with it.

The indentures of June 1697 mentioned above refer to the following (I have added punctuation for ease of reading): “buildings, Barnes, Stables and other out buildings, Yards, Gardens, Orchards, Backsides, Lands, Meadows, Leasows, Pastures, Feedings, Woods, Woodgrounds, Fishings, Comons, Comon of Pasture, Turbary, Ways, Waters, Easements”.

Large-scale Ordnance Survey maps, produced from the latter part of the 1800s onward (the one below was published in 1901) also show several outbuildings. What were they though? Thanks to the Valuation Office Survey, we know what almost all of them were (apart from one or two written illegibly) as of 1910-11. The relevant field book entry recorded the following structures:

  • Earth Closet (Brick & Tile)
  • Coal House (Wood & Iron)
  • Tool House
  • 3 Pig Pens
  • Cow Tying for [6?] + 4
  • 2 Bay Cart Shed & Granary over
  • Barn
  • Cow Tying for 5
  • Root House
  • Cow Tying for 5 & Loft over
  • Stable for 2
  • Trap House
  • Loose Box & [Hack Stable?] for 1
  • 2 Bay Cart Shed (Brick & Tile; Fair)
Extract from a large-scale Ordnance Survey map published in 1901. It shows a road running from the near the bottom left corner to near the top right corner. To the left side of the road field and property boundaries are shown, along with houses and other buildings. Lower House is named on the map extract, and I have added a green-bordered to highlight its position. The positions of two water pumps, a guide post, an Ordnance Survey bench mark and a well  are also shown on the map.
Extract from a 25 inch to the mile scale Ordnance Survey Map (published 1901) showing Lower House (circled) and surrounding buildings and structures at Waters Upton. Map reproduced with the permission of the National Library of Scotland ⇗ under a Creative Commons licence ⇗.

I hope to write in more detail about earth closets, cow tyings, root houses and other buildings enumerated by the Valuation Office Survey, in a separate post at a later date. For now, I will simply say that a recent estate agent’s brochure ⇗ lists the Lower House’s outbuildings as a converted barn (laid out as a home office with WC and kitchen), three garages, and a workshop. Also, the earth closet has long since been replaced by indoor WCs!

Dining & Drawing Rooms, Kitchen, Back Kitchen…

The Valuation Office Survey, which noted that the main house was of brick and tile, and in fair condition, also detailed the rooms inside it:

  • Dining & Drawing Rooms
  • Kitchen
  • Back Kitchen
  • Pantry
  • 4 Bedrooms
  • 2 Attic Rooms
  • 1 Cellar

There is still a dining room and a drawing room, according to the aforementioned estate agent’s brochure. That brochure also shows a number of changes to the functions of some of the rooms. The ground floor featured a kitchen/breakfast room, a family room / playroom, a utility room, a boot room and an integral double garage. Upstairs meanwhile, it appears that one of the bedrooms on the first floor had become a family bath/shower room, while the attic rooms, the second floor of the house, had been converted into two bedrooms and a bathroom, with a study area on the landing.

So, who lived in a house like this (to paraphrase the catchphrase used in TV show Through The Keyhole)? That is a question I will return to in future posts.

To be continued.